Wednesday, November 07, 2012

America's Drone War: A Moral Black Box

Pakistani drone strike victims

Jason Berry writes in "The Global Post",

In In his 2009 Nobel Peace Prize acceptance speech, President Obama cast war as a necessary evil.
Referring to just war theory, a classical underpinning of military ethics, Obama said, “War is justified only when certain conditions were met; if it is waged as a last resort or in self-defense; if the force used is proportional; and if, whenever possible, civilians are spared from violence.”
“For most of history, this concept of ‘just war’ was rarely observed,” he continued, citing the Third Reich and other examples. “Modern technology allows a few small men with outsized rage to murder innocents on a horrific scale.”
Then came Obama’s caveat, and a shape of things to come: “There will be times when nations — acting individually or in concert — will find the use of force not only necessary but morally justified.”
Technology is the moral black box that lies between those “few small men” in remote geographies of militant Islam, and teams of American military personnel who target them in front of closed-circuit screens, peering into the places of their hunted lives, programming drone attacks like a surreal video game.
The programmers go home to supper, wives and children while the Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs) rain fire on villages half a world away, obliterating those deemed guilty, sometimes, and, too often, blowing up innocent people caught at the wrong end of time and history.
When Obama wrote his own war doctrine referencing just war theory in the post-9/11 era, he did so as a president who perhaps more than any other leader in American history has relied on the secret killing of individuals to advance his administration’s policy goals. And when Obama wrote those words, he put himself on a continuum of history and of mankind’s thinking about the idea of war that dates back to at least the 4th century.
“The wise man will wage just wars,” wrote St. Augustine (354-430 AD) in The City of God. “For if they were not just, he would not wage them, and would therefore be delivered from all wars.”
Nine centuries later, St. Thomas Aquinas drew on Augustine and Aristotle in arguing that war must have a purpose beyond self-gain: peace should be its raison d’etre. In a time when warlords roamed parts of Europe, Aquinas insisted that only the state should wage war.
“Drones are not immoral per se, but how they are used presents serious moral and legal problems,” Professor Tobias L. Winright, a theologian at Saint Louis University and coauthor of After the Smoke Clears: The Just War Tradition and Post War Justice told GlobalPost. “Is it a last resort? Are we using force without intending to kill civilians?”
Winright references a December 17, 2009 strike in Yemen that killed Saleh Mohammed al-Anbouri, a militant linked to Al-Qaeda. The Navy missile also killed 41 civilians, of whom 22 were children. “Are civilian deaths collateral damage?” continues Winright. “Is the policy doing things to blur the reality?”
“President Obama and his administration have a policy that any male 18 or older can de facto be regarded as a militant. That is making criterion almost a dead letter. Human rights groups see this as a serious dead letter.”
Thomas Powers, author of Intelligence Wars and other books on the CIA, is more blunt.
“Drones are an unreliable and conspicuous way of killing individuals,” he told GlobalPost. “With drones we have no way to tell who we are killing. It’s abrogating a right to ourselves that no organization should have. It’s arbitrary and driven by politics. What seems inevitable today is going to cause you trouble tomorrow. Ask yourself if the United States would accept the right of another country to decide who among Americans they would kill. There are probably people in Arizona allied with drug cartels. Would we allow Mexican forces to use drones against them? Hell, no.”
“Other commanders in chief have presided over wars with far higher casualty counts. But no president has ever relied so extensively on the secret killing of individuals to advance the nation’s security goals,” wrote Greg Miller of the Washington Post in December


Anonymous said...

интернет знакомства с телефоном

знакомства с девушками для интернета

веб интернет знакомства бесплатно;u=741389

бесплатные интернет знакомства без смс

бесплатные интернет знакомства фото;u=38576

интернет знакомства анжеро судженск

знакомства фото видео интернет

интернет знакомства в снежногорске

бесплатные интернет порно знакомства

интернет знакомства в уфе бесплатно

сайт интернет знакомств без смс

Anonymous said...

интернет знакомства бугульма

видео чаты интернет знакомств

порно интернет знакомства

интернет знакомства шахты;u=145802

интернет знакомства вологда

интернет знакомства без активации

интернет знакомства в балаково

найти сайт интернет знакомств

интернет знакомства в санкт петербурге

интернет знакомства во владивостоке

воронеж интернет знакомства без регистрации

Anonymous said...

интернет знакомства в смоленске

интернет знакомства порно фото

интернет знакомства в ставрополе

знакомства для виртуального интернета

интернет знакомства без регистрации челябинск

бесплатные реальные знакомства для интернета

интернет знакомства владикавказ

интернет знакомства для взрослых

интернет знакомства в россии

интернет знакомства в новочеркасске

интернет знакомства без регистрации иркутск

Anonymous said...

интернет знакомства 15 лет

лабинск интернет знакомства

знакомства для интернета в г

интернет знакомства в уфе бесплатно

интернет знакомства нефтекамск

интернет знакомства белово

ухта интернет знакомства;u=34

интернет знакомства реально бесплатно

интернет знакомства индивидуалки

сеть интернет знакомств

интернет веб знакомства

Anonymous said...

ernvp [url=]beats by dre outlet[/url] zrxfku venm [url=]cheap beats[/url] twvupl boha [url=]cheap beats by dre[/url] fhpgac adapx [url=]beats by dre outlet[/url] fdkdul lhach [url=]beats by dre sale[/url] ljydj oiywy [url=]beats by dre sale[/url] hugfy sku

Anonymous said...

zcbqh [url=]beats by dre sale[/url] aozett ahpk [url=]beats by dre sale[/url] powwhb ezdx [url=]beats headphone[/url] zacxkv ywopq [url=]beats by dre outlet[/url] xndwtx kkxto [url=]beats by dre sale[/url] upkrl ywlln [url=]cheap beats[/url] imphk xrs

Anonymous said...

tahk tnfv koha [url=]moncler[/url] skjond zoroca [url=]louis vuitton outlet[/url] yjwezs [url=][/url] nwuipf zlydqc [url=][/url] iufykc [url=]louis vuitton online shop[/url] ioibqu [url=][/url] lapooh hybhhzm

Anonymous said...

Zixpgs [url=][b]hemres online[/b][/url] hermes myth Dgoxfd Qojqwa hermes bag