Courtesy Of "Work In Progress"
[Adapted from a speech given at the Forum on FBI repression, organized by the Jericho Movement, with Kent Ford and Arthur Miller at Portland State University, March 12, 2011.]
I have been asked to share my experiences and knowledge of government repression with you tonight, not to scare you, but so that we can deal with it and build stronger and more effective movements today for social and economic justice, locally, nationally and globally. I want to thank Adam Carpinelli and the Jericho Movement for organizing this event.
First a few general comments: We live in a society that is very unequal and is growing more so.
Officially, more than 40 million are below the official poverty line, and 14 million are officially unemployed. Another 12-15 million have given up looking or are working part-time and want to work full-time. Unemployment rates for Blacks are twice that for whites. Millions have lost their homes; 50 million people have no health insurance. Access to quality and affordable higher education is being taken away. Even more criminal is the 2 million plus people the government has imprisoned, almost 1 million of whom are African-American and 400,000 are Latino/a.
Globally, we see a similar trend with more of the income and wealth concentrated in a few hands, hunger and poverty rampant with less and less public services such as affordable education and healthcare. The environment is truly at risk.
Private sector unions have been greatly weakened by a 30-year corporate offensive. The Republican Party, along with most of corporate America, is now set to destroy unions of government workers and to privatize the public sector. It is not all gloom and doom. What is very inspiring, whether we are talking about Wisconsin, Egypt, Tunisia, Libya and many other places is that people are standing up, losing their fear and changing the world in profound ways. We are living in a world historic moment, rebellion is in the air-I urge you all to become even more a part of this global uprising.
What is happening today in some ways reminds me of the global uprisings in the 1960's, in Vietnam, France, Mexico, U.S., etc. Many of the gains that were won in the 1960's in the U.S. (such as the growing number of low income students, black, Latino/a, Asian-American but also working class whites in universities, growth in college scholarships, reductions in police brutality, better health and safety on the job, medical care for retired people, reductions in poverty, civil rights, ending the U.S. war against Vietnam) did not come from great Presidents but from people organizing and putting their bodies on the line demanding change. The response by those in power was to meet some of the demands, e.g., the end of legal discrimination but not the end of poverty, but also to repress and attack in different ways individuals and movements working for reformist and fundamental change in the society. This is not to say that we did not make some mistakes or that repression was the only cause of the decline of many of these movements but that it was a major factor. I also do not want to romanticize the 60's and 70's-there were many courageous people who accomplished a lot, but most people were not activists. It is at least as pressing today for building movements that link the struggles against U.S. militarism and the occupation of Iraq, Afghanistan with struggles for global justice, and for economic and labor and social and gender and racial justice for ending poverty and for immigrant rights and taxing the wealthy and against budget cutbacks and repression. By sharing knowledge of the past we can make our groups, and movements much stronger today. Much organizing is already happening, but we all have a responsibility to learn more about what is going on and act in ways small and big, individually and collectively to create a world based on meeting human needs rather than on serving the profits of the multinational corporations and their wealthy leaders. This is a difficult but very exciting time to be alive, globally and nationally.
Although we are told by the media and in schools that we have the right to protest, to organize, to speak up, these rights have been and will be violated by those in power, the police and the right-wing.
Let me turn to my experience with the FBI and government repression.
I participated actively in the anti-war movement and student organizing and student movements in the Boston area in the late 1960's. I spent 45 days in jail for this. I moved to San Diego in fall, 1970 to teach Economics at San Diego State University (SDSU). I was very active there against the Vietnam War, on and off campus, and in community organizing. Death threats, heavy surveillance and arrests on false charges against me began in spring 1971. Harassment escalated in the summer and fall of 1971-particularly after the Republican Convention announced it would be in then President, Richard Nixon's favorite city, San Diego in the summer of 1972.
The effort to fire me from my job as an assistant professor of economics at SDSU intensified in 1971-1972. The FBI visited my employer, and there was complicity on the part of Governor Ronald Reagan in openly political charges against me such as that I gave preference for admission into my classes to women and students of color. After three lengthy hearings that all ruled in my favor, and in spite of very large demonstrations supporting me, the State University system still fired me although I was voted best teacher by students at San Diego State University. Even the conservative American Economics Association ruled it was a case of political discrimination and yet after a lengthy court case, the California Supreme Court ruled that San Diego State University did not have to restore my faculty position.
In the early 1970's, in spite of repression, there was a strong movement against the Vietnam War, with a growing involvement of active duty and ex-military, and a strong Chicano movement both on campuses such as the local MEChA's, and farmworker support and in the barrios. There was also a strong Black movement at San Diego State with many ex-prisoners, who had been politicized in prison playing an important role. There was a San Diego based movement that I was part of, planning protests for the August 1972 scheduled Republican convention. We were planning massive non-violent direct action plus a lot of educating about struggles throughout the world. Because of this organizing, Nixon eventually moved the convention to Miami. He claimed it wasn't because of the planned protests although that was definitely the reason. Those in power will never admit that resistance and protest can lead to victories for those protesting, but it does.Remember this when you question whether active protest and resistance is futile.
All of the tactics that became identified as COINTELPRO, were used against us. I will focus on what happened to me, but I was part of a larger movement that faced these attacks. For example, all that happened to me also happened to the Brown Berets, a national Chicano group committed to Chicano rights and self-determination, which had a San Diego chapter. In my case, it involved coordination between the FBI, Nixon's Watergate team who broke into the Democratic Party headquarters at the Watergate Hotel in D.C., San Diego police and sheriffs and a fascist group funded by and closely working with the San Diego FBI office, the Secret Army Organization (SAO).
First, a few words about COINTELPRO. It is short for "Counterintelligence Program."
COINTELPRO was/is a program coordinated by the FBI to "expose, disrupt, misdirect, discredit or otherwise neutralize" individuals and groups. It supposedly started in 1968 and ended in April 1971 after it was exposed through people liberating FBI files in Media, PA. Although COINTELPRO officially ended in 1971, it continued (in a somewhat less extreme form) without the name up to September 11, 2001. Since then we are going backwards towards more police powers, infiltration and framing of activists. Much of the Patriot Act and the increased power being given to the FBI legalizes COINTELPRO-like tactics, whose primary target today is the Arab-American and Muslim communities, but it also provides weapons to be used against all those working for social change, such as with the raids in Chicago and Minneapolis against solidarity activists in fall, 2010.
A common tactic in the 1970's was calling people before a grand jury for supposed knowledge of a crime and then asking them to name the meetings they attended, other attendees, discussions etc. If people refused to testify, they were offered immunity, and if they continued to refuse to give names, to snitch, they were given contempt of court and often had to serve for the length of the grand jury-sometimes a year or even longer. They are again repeating this repressive tactic. It is important that people do not talk and do not cooperate with these grand jury fishing expeditions. They want to destroy our solidarity. We need to support our comrades called before grand juries.
Brian Glick, in his excellent pamphlet, "War at Home" on COINTELPRO, focuses on four methods used against U.S. activists. I will give a few examples from my own experience.
1. Infiltrate groups-Although no group I worked with in San Diego planned or carried out any violent actions, and many groups were purely educational, 20 people I knew in these groups turned out to be police or FBI agents or informers, and many worked for both. They worked hard to cause divisions among individuals and groups. Some but not all were provocateurs.
2. Psychological warfare-the FBI visited my employer, San Diego State University to get me fired, they visited landlords where I lived to get us evicted. They opened my mail, and monitored my checking accounts. We got anonymous phone calls about people being agents who I am sure weren't. Don't call someone a snitch or agent or informant without being sure.
3. Harassment through the legal system-There were many, many arrests. I usually beat the charges, but a lot of time and energy was spent defending myself. One example where I didn't beat the charges, but was innocent, was in 1973. My friend and fellow activist Pete Mahone and I were sentenced to 90 days in Chino State Prison for obstructing a train transporting Vietnam War supplies, based on the false testimony of four undercover police sheriffs who had infiltrated various progressive groups.
4. State sponsored violence-The FBI sponsored groups which did firebombings, slashed tires of my cars, issued continual death threats, and put out a wanted poster on me distributed in San Diego in late 1971 and early 1972. The Secret Army Organization, a group financed from FBI funds and led by an FBI informant, shot into a collective I lived in, with the bullet permanently injuring a member of the collective, Paula Tharp, in January, 1972.
Howard Barry Godfrey, a well-paid FBI informant and head of the Secret Army Organization (SAO) admitted almost a year later in court to driving the car the night of the shooting but claimed another SAO member did the actual shooting. After the shooting, other FBI agents in San Diego covered up the crime and hid the evidence, such as the gun used in the shooting.
The head of the FBI in LA, working with SD FBI, at that time was Richard W. Held who has been involved in the cases against many activists and political prisoners such as Judi Bari, Leonard Peltier and Geronimo Pratt.
After the shooting, threats and harassment continued. After the SAO began threatening liberals as well as radicals and bombed a pornography theater where some police were present, the San Diego police demanded that the FBI reveal their informants in the Secret Army Organizations. Many of its members were arrested in the summer of 1972 on numerous charges. Government lawyers hired by the FBI claimed various privileges, including the privilege to not have to reveal much of their behavior. The full FBI involvement in this attempted murder didn't come out although one FBI agent was forced to resign. Godfrey, the FBI informant and provocateur in the Secret Army Organization (SAO) didn't go to prison although two other members of the SAO did.
What is the relevance of this past history?
First, COINTELPRO supposedly ended in April 1971, but everything that was part of COINTELPRO continued against me for many years, e.g., phone taps and opening my mail, FBI and Red Squads of police departments visiting employers and potential employers. Most of this has been revealed through Freedom of Information Act requests. FBI criminality has continued against other groups and individuals such as the American Indian Movement, La Raza Unida Party in Texas, CISPES, Judi Bari and Earth First and radical environmental and animal rights activists, and recent protesters against the Democratic and Republican National Convention, and many others. So we cannot accept their claim that COINTELPRO ended in April, 1971, it continues today without that name. An example is the September, 2010 raids by the FBI in Chicago and Minneapolis.
Key repression has been and continues to be most fierce against Black, Chicano, Native American and other liberation movements. The FBI targeted César Chávez and the United Farm Workers although it was a totally non-violent and pacifist movement. They viciously targeted Martin Luther King. Although not as murderous and common, repression is also used against whites who challenge this oppressive global capitalist system. COINTELPRO and the police agencies have attacked most directly the Black Liberation movement, and also the Chicano, Puerto Rican and American Indian movements, but it does not stop there. All of us who stand up for justice and in solidarity become the enemy of those who run this country. In building movements for liberation, it is absolutely necessary that we support our sisters and brothers who have been victims of political repression, and that we support in ways small and big political prisoners such as Mumia Abu-Jamal, Leonard Peltier and others less well known. The Jericho Movement deserves a lot of credit for continuing to support political prisoners.
To weaken this repressive apparatus, we should learn about it and educate the left broadly about the limited nature of U.S. democracy. COINTELPRO-type behavior by the government requires secrecy because it so clearly violates the rhetoric of democracy and civil rights. It is analogous to the secrecy that the WTO, IMF, World Bank and multinational corporations require in order to impose their economic violence on people around the world. Let us intensify the pressure and expose these international organizations as well as the repressive apparatus at home and sponsored by the U.S abroad. The most vicious current government attacks are in the U.S. organized torture centers in Afghanistan and Guantanamo, and are on immigrants, mainly Muslim and/or Arab and Arab-American who are often held in secret with no rights, beaten, deported with no evidence whatsoever. Anti-communism was used as the excuse to justify much of the repression from the 1950's to the 1970's. So was calling someone a Black or Chicano militant. Today, the word "terrorist" is being used in the same way. Don't fall for these slanders; check out the evidence. The government and the media can lie, and do so often; be skeptical when you hear charges against someone (such as that they are terrorists or support terrorism), or you hear a movement being slandered.
Demand the release of Portland resident, Lumumba Ford, who committed no crime but was falsely called a terrorist and sentenced to 18 years in prison in 2003. The labels, anarchism and anarchist, are also used falsely to belittle movements and/or individuals as mindlessly violent whose supposed aim is to create chaos and disorder and destruction.
Learn about the Patriot Act, protest against it, prevent its extension, demand it be repealed, and support those who are being detained and deported. Also learn about the FBI's Joint Terrorism Task Force and resist Portland Police participation in it.
Some guidelines based on my experiences:
Infiltration-Infiltration will happen. If we are paranoid about people joining our groups, those in power win. We remain small and isolated. I often got anonymous phone calls about people who I was told were police agents who I am sure weren't. If people act suspiciously, a trusted person in the group can check into the person's background.
Psychological warfare-Try to build principled unity, don't believe everything you hear or read about other activists-check out rumors, limit gossip.
Legal system-Don't talk to the FBI or police or to a grand jury investigating political activists. Develop relations with movement lawyers, such as from the National Lawyers Guild, who will defend and advise you. Build support through petitions, through broad coalitions with people who you have differences with but who oppose government repression and spying, or spying done by private security firms. Try to get favorable stories in the media, get support from politicians.
Right-wing violence and harassment-Make it public. Have duplicates of your records and files. Limit their break-ins. Support each other. Work with mainstream groups to oppose them.
For example, in 2006, the Nazis from the National Socialist Movement who came to Olympia, many were from Portland. They threatened my life and others' in Olympia. We need to build broad coalitions for civil liberties and against white-supremacist groups.
It's important to be aware of what the government has done and is doing today-but not to be paralyzed into inaction from fear. If the fear of repression frightens us and others into inaction, those in power have been successful. Our best defense is a good offense, to continue to speak up and act in ways small and big and strategically to build alternatives and to fight the power.
In acting for justice, do not be constrained by the law, but consider the consequences of all possible actions. Don't try to get people to do what they don't want to do. Be honest, although details may have to be kept secret in direct action.
Build movements for justice that cross generations. Youth and students are key, but so are older people who haven't sold out-we can learn from each other. We didn't do enough of this in the 1960's and 1970's, e.g. learning from those who faced repression during the McCarthy witch hunts of the 1950's We need to build multi-generational movements and groups. Students and young people have played a huge role all over the world in liberation movements, e.g., today in Egypt, Tunisia and Libya. Older people, if they are not resting on their laurels as movement veterans and demanding to be followed, can make important contributions by sharing their experiences and knowledge. Age is one of the many divides we need to overcome.
I know I have talked about some events from 35-40 years ago but I would like to conclude by linking more closely the past to the present.
- One of the reasons I faced repression is because I was trying to build unity among different groups: campus, anti-war, women, Chicano, Black, worker, young, old, immigrant and non-immigrant, documented and undocumented workers. We must challenge racism and racial inequality in whatever we do.
If we are going to build a decent, humane society, we need to build coalitions, alliances, far stronger than we did in the 1960's and 1970's, utilizing those who see what we are facing as a destructive and exploitative global capitalist system (although not necessarily using those words). We need to challenge all of the -isms of racism, sexism, heterosexism, as we work for a goal of a different society. We also need to learn about and develop a vision of what kind of society we would like to live in, and share this knowledge with our friends, neighbors, family, fellow students, and many more. We should be courageous and bold, but we should not be arrogant or act morally superior. The more support we have, the more we reach out, the more difficult it is to isolate us and attack us.
- The role of the law and the courts and police are set up and used to maintain this unjust, racist, patriarchal and imperialist economic system. That was true in the 1960's and it is true today. Let us create a system where the dignity of all humans living in harmony with the environment are put at the center, where good food, adequate shelter, quality healthcare and education are rights for all, where militarism is ended. Fundamentally changing the status quo will often mean breaking the law. Our goal is justice, not legality. Voting and lobbying will not end injustice. Obama will not end injustice.
This does not mean proving how radical and militant we are by breaking windows or throwing rocks. These are tactics, not strategies. We must consider what is effective! Are we building a growing movement that can educate, organize and win, or are we trying to show how radical and macho we are?
- Repression is very real and serious but we should not exaggerate its severity. It is worse in many other countries such as Libya and Palestine, and people continue to resist injustice and oppression. So can we in the United States.
We can best honor those who have been murdered by our government and their agents, such as Fred Hampton of the Black Panther Party in Chicago in 1969, or Ruben Salazar killed during the Chicano moratorium in the protest against the Vietnam war in 1970 in Los Angeles, or the students at Kent and Jackson State in May, 1970, and thousands of others, not by mourning but by organizing, by building movements that put into practice solidarity across borders that are inclusive in all the important ways-class, gender, race, sexual orientation, language, immigrant status and age-that resist boldly and courageously all forms of inequality and environmental degradation. We need to challenge and stop U.S. aggression abroad, and work together to overthrow this insane profit system where farm workers make $7 an hour and are poisoned by pesticides, where over 2 million are in prison while Wall Street gets even wealthier, where immigrants are being scapegoated for the economic crisis through racist anti-immigrant laws like 1070 in Arizona, which other states are copying. Let us build a society based on cooperation, sustainability, where work is meaningful and production is organized around need and not greed, where global poverty is abolished, where the Earth is cherished and not destroyed, and equality in all forms and democracy become reality, not rhetoric. It may sound like dreaming but it is more realistic than thinking that the U.S. capitalist society can continue the way it is going for hundreds of years into the future.
Thank you for listening. Power to the People!
No comments:
Post a Comment