India Goes To War In Space

By Sudha Ramachandran
June 18, 2008
Courtesy Of Asia Times Online

BANGALORE - India's defense forces will be keeping an eye on yet another frontier - outer space. An Integrated Space Cell, which will be jointly operated by the country's three armed forces, the civilian Department of Space and the Indian Space Research Organization (ISRO) has been set up to utilize more effectively the country's space-based assets for military purposes and to look into threats to these assets.

Announcing the setting up of the Integrated Space Cell, India's Defense Minister Arackaparambil Kurian Antony said last week that it was being established because of "the growing threat" to India's space assets. "Offensive counter-space systems like anti-satellite weaponry, new classes of heavy-lift and small boosters and an improved array of military space systems have emerged in our neighborhood," the defense minister pointed out, stressing that these need to be countered.

Although its existence was announced only recently, the Integrated Space Cell has apparently been operational for several months. It functions under the Integrated Defense Services headquarters of India's Ministry of Defense.

Unlike an aerospace command, which is service-specific, that is, where the air force controls most of its activities, the Integrated Space Cell envisages cooperation and coordination between the three services as well as civilian agencies dealing with space.

India's army, air force and navy will work together in the Integrated Space Cell, coordinating with each other in utilizing space-based assets. "What the Ministry of Defense is aiming at is 'jointness of operations'," Lawrence Prabhakar, associate professor of political science at the Madras Christian College in Chennai told Asia Times Online.

The defense minister's announcement comes about 16 months after India's then chief of air staff, Air Chief Marshal Shashi Tyagi, told the media that India was "in the process of setting up an aerospace command to exploit outer space by integrating its capabilities". Training of "a core group of people for the aerospace command" had started, he said.

That announcement came less than a month after China used a medium-range ballistic missile to shoot down one of its own aging satellites, a Chinese Feng Yun 1C polar orbit weather satellite that it had launched into orbit in 1999. With that, China displayed to the world that it had the technology to knock out a satellite in space, expertise that only two other countries - Russia and the United States - have.

While the idea of an aerospace command was mooted by the Indian Air Force in the late 1990s, it does seem that the growing display of Chinese military might in space prompted India to act towards taking the first steps to dealing with the looming threat. Antony's reference to the threat posed by "military space systems in the neighborhood" to India's space assets indicates that the China factor was an important consideration in Delhi setting up the Integrated Space Cell.

While the China factor might have hastened the decision, there are broader reasons behind its setting up. "With the army, the air force and the navy relying on space-based communication satellites for reconnaissance, surveillance or operations and the Indian armed forces adopting a joint doctrine that enhances greater lateral integration between the three services, an Integrated Space Cell has become a necessity," Prabhakar said. Besides, "Such a cell is an organizational initiative, essential to the operational requirements of space-based assets for dual civilian-military operations and applications."

India's assets in space are considerable. Its space program has extended beyond launching satellites to plans to send unmanned and manned missions to space and then to the moon. Its space scientists are even eyeing Mars. Its achievements in launching satellites are formidable. In March this year, ISRO set a world record when it placed 10 satellites in orbit in a single mission.

India's expertise in building and launching satellites, and that too at a fraction of the price offered by other countries - India's satellites are 40% cheaper than its European and US competitors - has propelled it into a major commercial player. Its satellites bring in big money. Antrix, ISRO's commercial arm, earned more than US$153 million for the year ended March and it expects to corner 10% of the world market in the next few years.

Besides the foreign exchange, Indian satellites have contributed considerably to India's development objectives, including mass education, weather forecasting, disaster management and communications.

The satellites are a vital link in its defense as well. "The country's defense operations involve space-based sensors that would enhance force-multiplier effects of defense systems and are pivotal to guidance of India's ballistic missiles," Prabhakar said.

Its communication network would be broken, its security severely jeopardized and its capacity to defend itself against aggression damaged immeasurably if its satellites were to be knocked out. "India needs to protect or shield these satellites against killer satellites which Russia, China and the US possess."

And it is not just the hostile intentions of other countries that pose a threat to India's space assets and therefore its security. Debris in space is as lethal as an attack.

It is to look into the kind of threats and challenges that India's space assets face that the government has set up the Integrated Space Cell. "A long-term goal of the cell would be to robustly integrate space and ground operations for civilian and military objectives," said Prabhakar.

India's expression of its intentions to set up an aerospace command and its announcement of the Integrated Space Cell has raised concern in some quarters that India is entering the arms race in space.

Such fears might be premature, given that the Integrated Space Cell is at a very rudimentary stage. "India is just putting in place a very minimal budget initiative that will take several years to develop," argued Prabhakar.

"Besides satellites in space, India's space architecture of offensive and defensive systems are yet to be conceived, built and deployed," said Prabhakar, pointing to the different kinds of satellites, space-based laser systems, space stations and ground-based laser stations for offensive space operations that the "space superpowers" - the United States, Russia and China - have.

In the event of their satellites being knocked out by enemy action during a crisis, the US, Russia and China have the capability to launch substitute satellites into space at short notice. The US can move its satellites from one orbit level to another, higher level to escape being taken out by an enemy anti-satellite system (ASAT).

India can program a satellite launch only on a programmed sequence basis and not on short notice for rapid launches to replenish lost satellites, Prabhakar said. "India doesn't have even preliminary capability to defend its satellites," he said, adding "it will take another 15 to 20 years or more before India can put these systems in place."

For all its impressive achievements in building and launching satellites, India is decades away from establishing a fully-operational aerospace command. It has formidable capability in building satellites. It is now trying to find a way to defend them.

Sudha Ramachandran is an independent journalist/researcher based in Bangalore.

(Copyright 2008 Asia Times Online (Holdings) Ltd. All rights reserved.)